Hey Pandas, What Do You Think I Should Go With For The Comic I’m Working On? (Closed)

There’s a special kind of bravery required to ask the internet for creative feedback. You’re basically walking into a food court
holding two sample trays and yelling, “WHICH ONE IS MY SOUL?” And on Bored Panda’s Hey Pandas threads, people actually answer.
Lots of them. Passionately. Sometimes with the emotional intensity of a sports fan watching overtime.

If your “Hey Pandas, what do you think I should go with for the comic I’m working on?” post is now marked (Closed),
you’re at the best stage: you’ve collected opinions, and now you get to do the important partturn that chaotic, helpful pile of
feedback into a clear creative decision you can live with for months (or years) of drawing.

What a “Hey Pandas” thread really is (and why it works)

A Hey Pandas post is basically a public creative brainstorm. Readers can drop suggestions, vote with comments, and share
the kind of perspective you can’t get when you’ve been staring at your own characters for 400 hours and can no longer tell if the
protagonist’s haircut is “iconic” or “accidental ramen.”

The magic isn’t that the crowd is always rightit’s that the crowd is very good at reacting. Reactions are data. Your job is to
translate that data into decisions that support your story, your style, and your schedule.

Step 1: Figure out what you actually asked people to choose

Most creators think they’re asking one question, but the internet hears three.
Before you pick a “winner,” write down what your options really represent.

Common “comic choice” categories (even when you didn’t mean to ask them)

• Format: traditional pages, short strips, or vertical scroll.
• Art style: cartoony vs. semi-realistic; clean lines vs. textured chaos; cute vs. grim.
• Color: full color, limited palette, black-and-white, or “mostly grayscale until feelings happen.”
• Character design: silhouettes, outfits, hair, facial structure, “does this villain look like a youth pastor?”
• Tone: comedy, drama, horror, slice-of-life, or genre mashup.
• Readability choices: panel flow, font, balloon placement, and how much text is too much text.

If you don’t label the category, you risk choosing the most popular option for the wrong reason.
Example: People may “prefer” Option B not because the story direction is better, but because Option B is easier to read on a phone.
That’s not a minor detailthat’s a publishing strategy.

The Big Four decisions that make readers commit

1) Choose the format that matches your pacing (and your life)

A traditional page-based comic is great when you want dramatic reveals, controlled page turns, and strong composition.
Short strips are amazing for punchlines and consistency: readers know what they’re getting, and you can post regularly without
drawing 12 backgrounds per update.

Vertical scroll (webtoon-style) rewards momentum. It’s built for suspense beats, rhythmic reveals, and mobile reading.
But it also changes how you stage scenes: fewer “page-wide” moments, more “beat-to-beat” transitions.

Your best format is the one you can produce without burning out. A finished comic in a “good” format beats a perfect format that
lives forever in your notes app like a gentle, judgmental ghost.

2) Pick an art style that supports clarity first, aesthetics second

Style is a promise. If your comic leans comedic, simpler shapes and expressive faces make jokes land faster.
If it’s noir or horror, heavy shadows and texture can build mood immediately.
If it’s action-heavy, clean silhouettes and readable choreography matter more than eyelash rendering.

Here’s a practical test: can a new reader understand what’s happening in a panel from three feet away?
If your answer is “yes, but only if they squint with devotion,” simplify somethingline weight, backgrounds, or costume noise.

3) Decide on color like a filmmaker chooses lighting

Full color is emotionally powerful, but it’s also a production multiplier. Limited palettes can create a signature look while keeping
you sane. Black-and-white can be gorgeousespecially if you commit to strong contrast and intentional spotting of blacks (and don’t
treat it like “color later, maybe”).

If your Hey Pandas replies keep praising one option as “more professional,” check whether they mean:
more readable, more cohesive, or more like something they already buy.
Each of those compliments points to a different fix.

4) Lock the tone before you lock the details

Your tone is your contract with the reader. If your concept is heartfelt and sincere, a goofy style can still workbut you must steer
expressions, pacing, and dialogue toward emotional truth. If your concept is a comedy, the punchline needs space, timing, and facial
acting more than ultra-detailed scenery.

Step 2: Build a mini “comic bible” so you don’t get voted off your own island

Before you choose between Option A and Option B, write a one-page “comic bible” that answers:

• Logline: one sentence describing what your comic is about.
• Core theme: what you want readers to feel or think afterward.
• Main cast: 2–4 characters with clear roles and contrasts.
• Rules of the world: what can and can’t happen (even in comedy).
• Update reality: how often you can produce pages/episodes without chaos.

Now your community feedback has something to “snap” onto. If a suggestion clashes with your logline or schedule, it’s not “bad”
it’s just not aligned.

Step 3: Script choices that make drawing easier (and collaboration possible)

Whether you’re writing for yourself or a team, a comic script is an instruction set: what happens, what we see, what we hear,
and how the page flows. You don’t need fancy software, but you do need clarity.

A simple scripting approach that stays readable

• Page/Scene goal: what changes by the end of this page?
• Panel list: 3–7 panels per page (as a starting point), each with a clear action beat.
• Dialogue limits: cut lines until balloons don’t feel like they need their own zip code.
• Notes to self: mood, lighting, and important props (not a novel-length paragraph unless needed).

If your Hey Pandas thread is split between two options, try scripting the same scene in both styles. You’ll learn fast which one
supports your story and which one looks cool but fights you every step.

Step 4: Panel flowprotect the reader’s brain like it’s a fragile houseplant

Comics live and die by flow. When flow works, readers don’t notice itthey just feel the story.
When flow fails, readers start rereading balloons like they’re decoding a treasure map, and that’s when you lose them.

Three flow rules you can apply immediately

1. One beat per panel (most of the time): if you cram two actions into one panel, you’ll confuse the moment.
2. Establish space early: show where characters are before you zoom into faces and hands.
3. Use contrast for emphasis: quiet page → big reveal, busy page → silent panel, etc.

Lettering and balloons: the invisible craft that decides whether people read your comic

If a lot of commenters said “Option B is easier to follow,” they might be reacting to lettering and balloon placementnot just art.
Lettering is reader experience. Reader experience is survival.

Practical lettering habits that boost readability

• Plan balloon placement early: don’t cover faces, hands, or important visual jokes.
• Avoid “tangents”: awkward near-touches between balloons and art that create visual tension.
• Use balloon styles intentionally: rough balloons for monsters, wavy for distress, etc.but don’t overdo it.
• Stop double-spacing sentences: comics are not typewritten letters from 1997.

If you only make one production upgrade, make it lettering. Great lettering can elevate decent art; bad lettering can sabotage
brilliant art.

If you ever want to pitch: know what publishers actually say they want

Even if you’re not pitching today, it’s useful to understand the “industry reality” behind some feedback.
When strangers say “This feels publishable,” they might be responding to the kind of packaging publishers describe publicly:
clear concept, consistent team, readable storytelling, and a format that fits the market.

Two reality checks from major publishers

• Some publishers won’t review unsolicited ideas. That’s why building a public body of work matters:
  publish, post, and let your portfolio be searchable.
• Some publishers spell out proposal requirements. Those requirements quietly teach you what “professional-ready” looks like:
  synopsis, audience clarity, sequential storytelling samples, and a coherent visual package.

The takeaway isn’t “you must chase a publisher.” It’s that public guidelines can help you build a comic that’s clear, consistent,
and ready for readersno matter how you release it.

Indie route: treat your comic like a product and a relationship

If your Hey Pandas thread shows strong enthusiasm, that’s a signal you might be ready to build a small launch plan:
newsletter, posting schedule, sneak peeks, and a clean “start here” page.

A creator-friendly mini launch checklist

• Define your “episode unit”: page, strip, or scroll chapter.
• Create a buffer: stockpile 2–6 updates before you go public.
• Make sharing easy: one sentence pitch + one strong image.
• Reward loyalty: behind-the-scenes sketches, process posts, or Q&As.

Community feedback isn’t just about tasteit’s about connection. People support what they feel invited into.

Legal and ethics basics (aka: don’t accidentally step on a rake)

If your comic is original, treat it like an asset. Keep dated files, export final pages, and track what you publish and when.
If you ever need to protect your work, having clean documentation is a gift to Future You.

Also, be mindful of the current cultural and industry climate around authenticity and generative AI. A lot of readers care about
human-made work and the integrity of the creative process. Whether you use AI tools or not, be transparent and respect platform
and publisher rulesbecause “surprise controversy” is a terrible marketing plan.

How to read the “Hey Pandas” replies without losing your mind

Here’s a simple way to turn a closed thread into a decision:

1) Sort comments into three buckets

• Clarity notes: “I couldn’t tell what was happening,” “This reads better,” “I got confused here.”
• Taste notes: “I like this vibe,” “This style is cuter,” “This feels more serious.”
• Projection notes: “You should make it about X,” “This reminds me of Y,” “I want this genre instead.”

Clarity notes are gold. Taste notes are useful. Projection notes are optional seasoningadd only if it matches your recipe.

2) Look for patterns, not volume

Ten comments repeating the same issue (“I can’t read the text”) matter more than fifty comments saying “Option A!!!” with no reason.
Your goal is to learn why people react the way they do.

3) Make one decision, then set one rule

Example: “I’m going with the limited palette.” Now set a rule: “Accent color appears only when the character lies.”
That turns a choice into a storytelling tool.

A concrete example: turning two popular options into one smarter plan

Let’s say your thread looked like this:

• Option A: clean line art, bright colors, simpler backgrounds (lots of votes).
• Option B: moodier shading, textured brushes, more detailed environments (lots of praise).

Instead of choosing A or B, you can choose a hybrid plan:

• Default look: Option A for speed and consistency (weekly output stays possible).
• Story peaks: borrow Option B texture/shading only for key scenes (reveals, nightmares, flashbacks).
• Reader clarity rule: if a panel needs a second look to understand, simplify it.

This approach respects the crowd’s taste and your production realitywithout forcing you into an all-or-nothing choice.

Creator experiences: what it feels like after you ask “Hey Pandas” (500-ish words of real-world truth)

Most creators expect feedback to be a neat arrow pointing toward “the correct option.” What you usually get is more like a weather report:
high winds of enthusiasm, scattered showers of brutal honesty, and one person insisting your comic should be set in space because
“space sells.” The first emotional beat is often reliefpeople care enough to answer. The second beat is confusionbecause they don’t
agree. And the third beat, if you handle it well, is momentum: you finally see your comic through someone else’s eyes.

A common experience is discovering that readers respond to confidence as much as craft. When your options look tentative,
commenters will try to “solve” your comic by rewriting it for you. But when your options feel intentionalclear tone, clear format,
clear premisefeedback becomes sharper: people stop redesigning your whole house and start telling you which room feels cramped.
That’s when comments shift from “Do a different genre” to “That balloon placement is tripping me up” or “I love the character’s
expression in the second panel.” Those are fixable, actionable notes.

Another frequent moment: you realize the internet is a mirror, not a map. People vote based on their reading habits, nostalgia,
and what they already like. Some will prefer anything that looks like a traditional comic page. Others will prefer anything that
reads cleanly on a phone. Some will choose the option that resembles a popular style because it feels familiar and therefore
“professional.” None of that is wrongbut it means the “winning option” can reflect audience identity as much as it reflects your
story’s needs. The skill you build here is editorial judgment: listening deeply without surrendering authorship.

Creators also tend to experience an unexpected productivity spike after a thread closes. There’s something about public feedback
that makes the project feel more reallike it’s graduated from “idea” to “thing people are waiting for.” That can be motivating,
but it can also create pressure. The healthiest pattern is to convert hype into a small, repeatable system: a buffer of pages,
a realistic update cadence, and a consistent workflow you can maintain when life gets loud. Your comic doesn’t need you to be
inspired every day; it needs you to show up on the days you feel like a soggy tortilla.

Finally, many creators discover the best “experience-based” rule of feedback: if a note shows up repeatedly, fix it. If a note
shows up once but hits you in the gut, investigate it. And if a note asks you to become a completely different creator, smile,
say “thanks,” and keep driving your own car. The goal of asking Hey Pandas isn’t to get permissionit’s to get perspective.
Your comic will be strongest when the crowd helps you see more clearly, while the final choice still sounds like you.

Conclusion

A closed Hey Pandas thread is not a final verdictit’s raw material. Use it to improve clarity, strengthen your format choice,
and commit to a style you can produce consistently. Pick the option that best serves your story and your workflow, then
set one or two simple rules that make your comic feel intentional from page one. The internet can help you see your comic more
clearly, but you’re still the one holding the pen. (And the eraser. And the caffeine.)

SEO Tags