Kieran Culkin Rankings And Opinions

Short version: The “other Culkin” isn’t the other Culkin anymore. Between a star-making turn as Roman Roy in Succession, a scene-stealing performance in A Real Pain, and a resume that quietly aged into greatness, Kieran Culkin has become one of the most reliably electric actors working today. Below you’ll find a definitive, delightfully subjective ranking of his best workplus why critics (and increasingly, awards bodies) can’t stop talking about him.

Why Kieran Culkin Is Having a Moment

He’s the rare performer who looks effortless whether he’s detonating a boardroom with a one-liner, crumbling in front of a microphone, or deadpanning through a pop-culture cult classic. In the last few years he’s crossed the line from “great character guy” to “center-of-gravity star”: big-series anchor (Succession), festival darling (A Real Pain), and even a Broadway lead (Glengarry Glen Ross). That breadth is why “Kieran Culkin rankings” are funthey force you to compare peerless comedy timing with quietly devastating drama.

The Definitive Kieran Culkin Performance Rankings

#1 Roman Roy in Succession (2018–2023)

Roman is a walking paradoxferal and fragile, hilarious and haunted. Culkin threads Roman’s whiplash tone shifts so precisely that the character’s worst impulses land like punchlines until they suddenly don’t. Watch the way he weaponizes swagger and then lets it dissolve; the micro-flinches give away a lifetime of emotional booby traps. Peak moments: the funeral meltdown, the finale’s almost-smile at the bar, and any scene where Roman realizes the adults in the room are only marginally more adult than he is.

#2 Benji in A Real Pain (2024)

As the talky cousin who masks grief with comic ricochet, Culkin turns riffy humor into x-ray vision. It’s a showcase for his superpower: making the crack in the voice part of the joke and the ache.

#3 Jason “Igby” Slocumb Jr. in Igby Goes Down (2002)

Before Roman, there was Igbya privileged, acidly funny teen who can’t stand phonies or himself. The role established Culkin as a lead who could lace a wisecrack with bruised humanity. It also proved he can carry a film without ever looking like he’s trying to carry a film.

#4 Wallace Wells in Scott Pilgrim vs. the World (2010) and Scott Pilgrim Takes Off (2023)

Wallace is proof that comedic economy can be lethal. Culkin fires off lines like paper airplanes with razor tips; the character steals scenes by barely moving. A decade later, his voice performance in the animated return is the same dry magic, just distilled.

#5 Richard Roma in Glengarry Glen Ross (Broadway, 2025)

Roma is a salesman and a shark, and Culkin plays him like a world-class racquet sport: setups, feints, a sudden kill shot. It’s the live-theater proof of what TV and film hinted athe can command a room with nothing but air, vowels, and velocity.

#6 Charlie in No Sudden Move (2021)

It’s a small role in Soderbergh’s knotty crime puzzle, but Culkin makes every beat countsnaky, nervy, and just dangerous enough to tint the whole frame.

#7 Jimmy in Lymelife (2008)

A sharp, melancholy indie where Culkin’s presence adds texture; he can tilt a scene from sweet to sour without raising his voice.

#8 Simon Boggs in She’s All That (1999)

Even as a teen, he had the rhythm. The movie is a time capsule; his timing ages like good sarcasm.

#9 Kevin in The Mighty (1998)

Early-career sincerity. You can already see the instinct to underplay and let the audience come to him.

#10 Fuller McCallister in Home Alone (1990)

The glasses. The Pepsi. The glint. A micro-role that somehow became macro-memorable.

How Critics Talk About Him

What keeps popping up across reviews: precision. Critics love that Culkin can pivot from irreverent to wrecked without signaling the turn, that his humor is really misdirection for feeling. With Roman Roy, they single out the physical choiceshow bravado collapses into a flinch; how a smirk can curdle into a plea. With Igby Goes Down, they noted that he found a fresh, biting register for a well-worn archetype. With A Real Pain, they point to a performance that keeps deepening as the jokes keep landing.

A Kieran Culkin Timeline (aka Why He Keeps Ranking High)

• 2002: Igby Goes Down signals he’s not just a scene-stealerhe can carry a movie.
• 2010: Scott Pilgrim vs. the World turns him into a quotable cult favorite.
• 2018–2023: Succession era; Roman Roy becomes the internet’s most problematic poet of pain.
• 2023: Returns as Wallace (voice) in Netflix’s Scott Pilgrim Takes Off.
• 2024: Awards-season coronation for Roman; critical glow for A Real Pain.
• 2025: Broadway lead in Glengarry Glen Ross. Theater kids and TV kids unite.

Ranking Methodology (So You Can Yell at Me Properly)

These rankings blend: (1) awards and major critics’ reception, (2) long-tail audience love (the roles people quote forever), (3) degree of difficulty (emotional high-wire acts score higher), and (4) career significance (what changed because of this role). When two roles were close, rewatch value broke tiesif you keep revisiting a performance and finding new cadences, it climbs.

Debates, Settled (For Now)

Is Roman Roy the best TV performance of the last decade?

Short list, long arguments. What nudges Roman near the top is not just the writing; it’s Culkin’s modulation. He converts cruelty into confession on a dime, and the character never stops surprising youeven at the end.

Is Igby Goes Down still essential viewing?

Absolutely. It’s a time capsule that feels weirdly current: that mix of privilege, disaffection, and razor wit maps neatly onto today’s culture. Also, it’s an early masterclass in controlled exasperation.

Comedy or dramawhere does he truly excel?

Yes. The funniest stuff often hurts (Roman), and the saddest stuff often cracks you up (A Real Pain). That overlap is his home field.

Where He Goes Next

Expect more shapeshifting. Post-Succession, he’s already toggled between prestige film and Broadway. He’s a natural fit for directors who like moral mazes and fast banterthe kind of roles where you can hear the gears turning until you realize they’re grinding bone.

Conclusion

Kieran Culkin’s rise wasn’t sudden; it was a long con powered by craft. The joke finally landed on us: the guy we thought was “the sarcastic one” is, quietly, one of the most complete actors of his generation. And yes, Roman tops the rankingsbut the bench is deep, and it’s getting deeper.

• Shift to A Real Pain. If you want to feel how Culkin bends tone, cue up a scene where Benji is barreling through jokes. The humor lands, sure, but the rhythm is what matters: he accelerates, then slams the brakes with a look that says, “I didn’t dodge the feeling; I just outran it for a second.” That cadence is why awards voters tend to check his box; you can sense the architecture underneath the looseness.

  Now try a palate cleanser: Scott Pilgrim. The trick here is restraint. Wallace hardly moves, but every line lands like a dart thrown from the couch. It’s a lesson in negative spacehow doing less, cleanly, is sometimes the entire assignment. When you place Wallace against Roman or Benji, the range pops: same face, different gravitational pull.

  For a live-theater stress test, imagine a mezzanine seat at Glengarry Glen Ross. Roma requires velocitythose rolling sales pitches can turn to mush if the actor can’t keep the engine humming. Culkin’s stage work clarifies the screen presence: he’s a tempo artist. Even when the text is a blizzard of consonants, he finds the groove and surfs it, never shouting to sell the moment.

  Finally, revisit Igby Goes Down to see the prototype. The film’s energy is younger, pricklier, but the Culkin DNA is already there: the deadpan that hides a fuse, the way vulnerability arrives sideways, the refusal to oversell. It makes the modern rankings feel less like a hot take and more like a throughlinethis was always the arc, we just needed time to catch up.

  So if you’re building your own list, here’s the practical approach: (1) watch for micro-choices (breath, posture, head tilts), (2) note how often you want to rewind a moment just to understand why it hit, (3) test the performances out of contextdo the scenes still hum when divorced from plot? With Culkin, they do. That’s why he ranks where he ranks.

  Taylor Brooks

  Share On Social

  Tags: A Real Pain best Kieran Culkin roles Igby Goes Down Kieran Culkin rankings Roman Roy Scott Pilgrim Succession